Thursday, March 3, 2011

Universalism: What It Is and Isn't

There has been a lot of controversy recently surrounding what amounts to a publisher's summary of a book that nobody has read. The blogs and social media are aflame and the battle lines are seemingly drawn. Bell v. Piper, the apocalyptic internet battle for the ages.

Bell is being accused, largely by those within John Piper's Neo-Calvinist/Neo-Reformed camp, of espousing universalism. While Piper's three word response via twitter, "Farewell, Rob Bell," is about as productive and mature as showing someone your middle finger, that is not the issue at hand. It has been well established by the thousands of electronic responses to this controversy that both: A. We should all probably wait to see what the book actually says before handing out such a "scary" label to Rob Bell and B. John Piper behaved more or less like an ass.

The term "universalism" being tossed around, however, scares many Christians. Why is this idea so scary? What does it really mean? Isn't this just evidence of the liberalizing forces within America pushing us toward some sort of wishy-washy relativistic idea that doctrine doesn't matter?

I'm glad you asked...

Christian Universalism, as opposed to Unitarian Universalism, does not involve the idea that all religious beliefs are equally valid and that one path to God works just as well as the next. If someone is claiming to be a Christian Universalist they are still making some sort of claim regarding the uniqueness of Jesus Christ, thus the designation of Christian. In the debate at hand, the issue of universalism is referring most directly to the eschatological fate of the human race. The position of a Christian Universalist in this case would be referring to the belief that through the power of the resurrection of Jesus Christ all of humanity will be saved either now or "at the end of all things."

This stands in fairly direct opposition to the traditional orthodox Christian position that those who are not "saved" during their present corporeal existence will one day be relegated to some sort of eternal torment  or "hell" (usually thought to be a big ass lake of fire).

The doctrine of hell is based upon a few key New Testament texts that refer to a lake of fire or gehenna (a burning trash heap outside of Jerusalem) as places essentially to be avoided at all costs. (Don't look in the Old Testament for any notions of hell, it just ain't there) These references usually stand as representations of the direct opposite of the Kingdom of God. The Kingdom of God is good, gehenna and fire lakes are bad.

The argument for hell is often made from a fairly asinine point of view, however, following the train of logic that: "1. I am a Christian so I am going to escape hell because I made the right choice 2. Those people are not Christians so they should be punished forever 3. Otherwise why should we even be Christians?"...
Sad isn't it?
While this is not entirely representative of all people who make arguments for hell, this deeply seeded idea of "fairness" often leads to using the aforementioned New Testament passages as "proof texts" showing why you are going to hell and I am not.

The most common motivation behind Christian Universalism, however, comes from pure unadulterated hope. When someone argues the point of view that maybe the power of Jesus' resurrection is enough to one day redeem all of humanity, most of the time it is because they hope that no one has to suffer eternal punishment and damnation. Christian Universalism seems to spring from what Jesus himself said is the second most important commandment "love your neighbor as yourself." The universal redemption of all of God's children sounds pretty "Christian" to me.

Universalism admittedly has to wrestle with the aforementioned New Testament passages, they can't be dismissed. We're talking hermeneutics here though folks. If those texts are read through the theological lens that God loves all of humanity so much as to send Jesus to die to redeem humanity then maybe...just maybe they may be talking about something else.

Anyone calling themselves Christians should hope that all will one day be redeemed. Christopher LaTondresse in an article for The Huffington Post rightly makes this point:


Those who believe God modeled the ultimate example of true love in the person of Jesus -- and who, therefore, aspire to love their fellow humans as they love themselves -- should also believe that, in the end, God's love will win the day. So is it really that radical to suggest that this belief should accompany the earnest hope that it is actually within the scope of God's sovereign power and unrelenting grace to reconcile all things to himself?

I, furthermore,  maintain that if you cannot at least entertain the possibility (and I emphasize the preceding phrase) that the love of God as revealed in Jesus Christ is big enough to, either presently or eschatologically redeem ALL of humanity then I maintain that either A) you have grossly underestimated the power of the incarnation or B) your God isn't as big as you think.

Ultimately, we don't know what will happen "at the end of all things." That is why humility is the key when we debate these things together as a Christian community. Tossing the word heretic around as though we cannot disagree with someone and both be called Christian is a sad way to operate. I believe, however, that our generation is tired of this sort of mud-slinging and am hopeful for the future that we look toward an open and safe atmosphere where we can disagree and debate in order to grow and come closer to the God we all profess to be following. 

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Welcome One and All

I've put this off for a very long time now. There is something inside of me that is diametrically opposed to the idea that we all need to chronicle all of our thoughts for everyone else to read. Balance that with a lifelong love affair with the written word and the expression of oneself through writing and you understand my dilemma. This being understood, I want to be a humble blogger. I don't purport to have any or all of the answers, I just want to have a part in the dialogue. I've been inspired you might say to jump in with both feet and give it a shot, and if you are reading this blog I look forward to your input.

The inspiration behind this new endeavor arises from a fairly simple and specific hope. The hope of this blog is twofold: 1) That those who feel out of place within "The Church" or seem to disagree with most of what "The Church" says will hear that it is ok to be different, we don't all have to agree. 2) That this blog will in some small way contribute to dialogue regarding things of a "theologically controversial nature." I am going to attempt to write at least weekly on unorthodox or taboo positions within the Christian Church that while admittedly outside the realm of the normative position deserve a seat at the table. I would also be open to suggestions about topics for discussion.

Debate is good. Disagreement is healthy. Diversity is beautiful. Differences don't have to be divisive.

Welcome to my humble offering, let's get controversial.